| 1800 |
| Brookfield | Cazenovia | DeRuyter | Greene |
| Hamilton | Jericho | Norwich | Oxford |
| Sangerfield | Sherburne |
| 1810 |
| Columbus | Coventry | German | Greene |
| Jericho | New Berlin | Norwich | Oxford |
| Plymouth | Preston | Sherburne | Smithville |
| Smyrna |
| 1820 |
| Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry | German |
| Greene | Guilford | McDonough | New Berlin |
| Norwich | Otselic | Oxford | Pharsalia |
| Plymouth | Preston | Sherburne | Smithville |
| Smyrna |
| 1830 |
| Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry | German |
| Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen | McDonough |
| New Berlin | Norwich | Otselic | Oxford |
| Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth | Preston |
| Sherburne | Smithville | Smyrna |
| 1840 |
| Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry | German |
| Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen | McDonough |
| New Berlin | Norwich | Otselic | Oxford |
| Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth | Preston |
| Sherburne | Smithville | Smyrna | Pensioners |
| 1850 |
| Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry | German |
| Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen | McDonough |
| New Berlin | North Norwich | Norwich | Otselic
|
| Oxford | Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth |
| Preston | Sherburne | Smithville | Smyrna |
| 1860 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry |
| German | Greene | Greene Village | Guilford |
| Lincklaen | McDonough | New Berlin | New Berlin Town |
| North Norwich | Norwich | Otselic | Oxford |
| Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth | Preston |
| Sherburne | Smithville | Smyrna | South New Berlin |
| 1870 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry |
| German | Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen |
| McDonough | New Berlin | North Norwich | Norwich |
| Otselic | Oxford | Pharsalia | Pitcher |
| Plymouth | Preston | Sherburne | Smithville |
| Smyrna |
| 1880 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Beaver Meadow / Otselic | Brisben / Greene |
| Columbus | County Jail - Norwich | County Poor House | Coventry |
| Earlville / Sherburne | German | Greene | Guilford |
| Lincklaen | McDonough | Mt. Upton / Guilford |
New Berlin |
| Norwich | Otselic | Oxford | Pharsalia |
| Pitcher | Plymouth | Preston | Rockdale / Guilford |
| Sherburne | Sherburne Quarter | Smithville | Smyrna |
| 1900 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry |
| German | Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen |
| McDonough | New Berlin | North Norwich | Norwich |
| 1st Ward - Norwich | 2nd Ward - Norwich | 3rd Ward - Norwich | 4th Ward - Norwich |
| Otselic | Oxford | Pharsalia | Pitcher |
| Plymouth | Preston | Sherburne | Smithville |
| Smyrna |
| 1910 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry |
| German | Greene | Guilford | Lincklaen |
| McDonough | New Berlin | North Norwich | Norwich |
| 1st Ward - Norwich | 2nd Ward - Norwich | 3rd Ward - Norwich | 4th Ward - Norwich |
| 5th Ward - Norwich | 6th Ward - Norwich | 7th Ward - Norwich | Otselic |
| Oxford | Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth |
| Preston | Sherburne | Smithville | Smyrna |
| 1920 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | Columbus | Coventry |
| German | Greene | Guilford | Guilford / Mt. Upton |
| Lincklaen | McDonough | New Berlin | North Norwich |
| 1st Ward - Norwich | 2nd Ward - Norwich | 3rd Ward - Norwich | 4th Ward - Norwich |
| 5th Ward - Norwich | 6th Ward - Norwich | Otselic | Oxford |
| Pharsalia | Pitcher | Plymouth | Preston |
| Sherburne | Sherburne / Earlville | Smithville | Smyrna |
| 1930 |
| Afton | Bainbridge | County Almshouse | Columbus |
| Coventry | Earlville | German | Greene |
| Greene TWP - East | Greene TWP - West | Guilford TWP - East | Guilford TWP - West |
| Lincklaen | McDonough TWP | New Berlin | New Berlin TWP |
| New York Women's Relief Camp | North Norwich TWP | Norwich TWP |
1st Ward - Norwich |
| 2nd Ward - Norwich | 3rd Ward - Norwich | 4th Ward - Norwich |
5th Ward - Norwich |
| 6th Ward - Norwich | Otselic | Otselic TWP | Otselic TWP / Beaver Meadow |
| Otselic TWP / Otselic | Otselic TWP / South Otselic | Oxford | Oxford TWP - East |
| Oxford TWP - West | Pharsalia TWP | Pitcher TWP | Plymouth TWP |
| Preston TWP | Sherburne | Sherburne TWP | Smithville TWP |
| Smyrna | Smyrna TWP |